When I read the article that Walter Benjamin wrote I was completely dumbfounded as to why he would write something like this. I was completely lost as to what he was trying to communicate to his reader. I was able to discern from the essay that the progress of technology was quick and innovative. I was also able to gather that most people are hateful toward change. As was indicated by his references to those who detested the invention of the camera when compared to the artistry of the painter. The issue was that the artist would spend hours recreating an image with his hand and tool while the photographer could take a snap shot and from that snap shot have almost a perfect rendition of the scene. This is problematic because now art (if photography is considered art) could be mass-produced and distributed to the masses.
However, Walter Benjamin argues that even with new inventions in art replacing old techniques, the aura of the art is not recreated. It is lost as when the actor in the movie is given multiple times to make a scene while the actor on stage has one chance and one chance only. The director of the movie can control the scene and the way the audience perceives the situation. He controls the camera and what the audience sees. On stage the audience controls what they look at, what they see.
If I could speak to Walter Benjamin I would like some further clarification as to what all the talk of art had to do with being Marxist. The epilog at the end of the article threw me off as to what the goal of the article actually was. I was under the impression that the main premise was that art, when mass-produced, is shared with everyone, but because of that the worth of the art is reduced. Instead, when I read the epilog I was confused with the talk of fascism and communism. How fascisms works to control art and technology and how communism uses art and technology to further itself. What does this have to do with the discussion of technological advances in art itself?
No comments:
Post a Comment